So, I’ve been tracking my eating with Lose It (the app for my phone and on the web) for a full month. A month ago, Michael and I sat down with some numbers, for example:
- The number which represents the dollar amount we spend monthly on food for me (Medifast – 5 meals a day, 30 days a month, $2.36 average cost per meal = $354 a month, plus shipping and dinners – probably $800 a month, all told)
- The number which represents Medifasts’ published expected weekly weight-loss (2-5 pounds)
- My total weight loss after four months – 16 weeks, exactly (~30 pounds, average of 1.875/ week)
- My average calorie intake daily (1000 kcal)
At the beginning of this month – we decided to play by the Medifast book. I got half an hour of exercise most days (yoga, walking, house cleaning) and oftentimes (2-3 times a week) got significantly more exercise than that. I not only watched my caloric intake – I watched fat, carbs, sodium. I stopped my daily glass of wine. I started drinking 2-3 cups of unsweetened green tea a day and mostly cut out diet soda. I maintained a regular sleep schedule (7-8 hours a night).
And this month, I’ve lost… 6.4 pounds.
So in four weeks, I’ve lost an average of 1.6 pounds a week. Well below the minimum weight loss promised by Medifast.
My promise to Michael, if that was the ending result, was to look at ways to wean myself slowly off Medifast and onto a low-calorie, no-added-sugar, low-carb diet. If I suddenly gain a metric boat load of weight – I can cease the process and evaluate what’s going wrong.
Medifast isn’t a miracle cure, and I didn’t expect it to be. But by that same token – I don’t believe I’m seeing the results I should be seeing. I didn’t expect to hit five pounds a week because of my thyroid. But I’m not even losing two pounds a week.
I look and feel better. I haven’t really hit a plateau yet. Don’t doubt that Medifast works – it does. What I doubt is that it works better than any other diet and exercise program, for me. Especially considering the cost.
Medifast has been valuable to me in that it’s retrained the way I look at and prepare food. I’m more aware of what being hungry feels like. And I’m also more aware when I’m reaching fullness. I have not, since I started Medifast, had more than a day or two where I ate until I felt over-full. I’ve realized that cravings are not orders from my body to indulge or over-indulge. And I’ve been able to say no and also to take tiny pieces of food to taste. I’ve been satisfied with that.
I’ve lost enough weight on Medifast that I can walk and do yoga without killing my joints. And the more I move, the more I start to really love my body. Every morning I get up and do some yoga or some stretches from when I was dancing. I’m still fat, but I’m strong and flexible. That feels good.
And maybe most importantly for me – Medifast took away a lot of the romance of food. Michael and I have talked about how we always looked at food as a way to achieve an awesome experience. I love food, and I always will. I take great joy in fresh fruit and veg; in fatty, cured meats; in creamy cheeses; in a rich, dark chocolate or cup of espresso. But most days, food isn’t romantic. Most days it’s just good. I cook chicken or fish and put a veg on the side and it’s tasty and cooked perfectly but it’s a standard meal. I relish it because it recharges my batteries and usually tastes pretty darn good. But I’ve stopped seeking orgasmic delight in food, 99% of the time.
I’ve not stopped seeking warmth or comfort in food – I’ve just changed the food I do that with. I cut myself half an ounce of cheese and gnaw on it like a mouse. I drink a cup of tea. Maybe I grab a handful of pistachios or walnuts or almonds.
Mostly, Medifast is a plan. You don’t pay for the meals so much as for the convenience of not having to think everyday - what am I going to eat? How is it going to make me feel? Will it give me enough energy to get through until lunch/dinner/snack?
Right now, I’m trying to consider how I would change that plan to take me off of it without derailing my progress. Michael asked me to think about what breakfast I would eat to take the place of my first medifast meal every morning.
I’m sort of at a loss. I’d like to avoid bread products and added sugar (so no oatmeal). I’d like to be able to parcel it out and grab it in the morning to eat at work. I do yoga each morning, so something heavier on protein is probably wise. So I’m researching.
Anyway – so there’s a diet update. I’ve lost a total of 35 pounds so far. I don’t want to feel rushed about losing this weight – I mean, I want to keep it off for good. But I don’t feel good spending so much money on a plan that I don’t think is helping me lose weight any faster than I could, on my own.