Skip to content

Drugs and Depression

From Dear Abby:

Last February, I printed a letter from Marc Galanter, M.D., the director of alcoholism and drug abuse at New York University Medical Center. In it he said: “(W)e know that illicit drug use changes the developing brain. Many young people smoke pot before their brain development is settled, and their chronic use of the drug can affect certain centers in the brain that control emotion and reason.

“Research shows that regular use … may also lead to mental health problems. Youth who use marijuana weekly have double the risk of depression later in life, and are three times more likely than non-users to have suicidal thoughts.”

I take exception to the second paragraph – I think this is a causal/correlative issue. Research shows that youths who use marijuana may have an increased risk of depression.  Which can mean a couple things:

  1. Marijuana screws up your brain and makes you more likely to be depressed. Or, more likely:
  2. People who suffer from depression look towards drugs (such as marijuana) to modulate their moods.

I am of the opinion that we (people, in general) create our own addictions as a means of maintaining control over our emotions. My biggest problem on this diet is that the way I dealt with my emotional issues was to binge-eat. It’s something I never really thought was unhealthy until I tried to change it. I’m at a place now where after breaking my food addiction for the most part, I have no methods to control and manage my emotions. It’s a constant struggle.

I’m sick of scientists spreading misinformation about drugs.  Drugs are probably bad, because chances are if you choose to do them, you have emotional problems you haven’t dealt with.  Especially if you start taking drugs (including tobacco and alcohol) at a young age. Choosing to deal with emotional problems by disguising them with an addiction to food or drugs just makes it more and more difficult for you to actually help yourself when you realize you’re not any happier than you were before.

On the other hand – plenty of people can eat brownies, drink alcohol or smoke marijuana in moderation as part of a fulfilling life.  The point is – you have to be old enough and know yourself well enough to see which group you’re part of.

I understand the necessity to discourage drug use among people as a means of reducing addiction and crime and etc, but come on. Don’t mislead people with “facts” that are actually just statistics you dressed up to support your point. Reasonable people can disagree on what statistics mean, but a lot of the crap trotted around about drugs is patently false. I’m not encouraging anyone to take drugs – that’s a highly personal choice and there are always dangers associated (if not physical, there are tons of legal repercussions) – I just take offense to the way the media chooses to paint them to discourage their use.

The letter from Dear Abby is about two parents spying on their kid’s internet conversations and finding out one of their kid’s friends is using. Abby says they should tell that kid’s parents (they should) but neglects to mention that the parents should tell their kid they’ve been watching his conversations and discuss their personal concerns about drugs with their kid.

4 Comments

  1. Michael wrote:

    As you said, “plenty of people can eat brownies, drink alcohol or smoke marijuana in moderation as part of a fulfilling life.” Sure, marijuana use by the depressed may be nothing more than an indicator of depression, but I think that argument only holds up on the day a depressed kid starts smoking pot.

    I would argue that the drug use “modulates the kid’s moods” at the expense of him not seeking out other remedies. I think the only true remedy for emotional issues is to face them and sort them out day by day, and in that sense marijuana is a distraction that is certainly harmful to any non-casual user. Same goes for alcohol or cake.

    Kids who truly feel they need to use drugs ought to be given soul-melting doses of LSD. That’ll sort them right out.

    Monday, April 28, 2008 at 12:29 pm | Permalink
  2. Kara wrote:

    I think I tried to make the point – that using a drug to modulate mood ultimately belabors the task of dealing with your emotional problems.

    I miss my cake distractions.

    Monday, April 28, 2008 at 12:38 pm | Permalink
  3. Michael wrote:

    Yeah, looking back I didn’t really say what I meant to so much as regurgitate your 4th paragraph. Sorry. What I meant to say was this:

    If smoking pot = not dealing with your issues = emotional problems, then I think smoking pot = emotional problems, by the transitive property of badness. Can you still make an argument for correlation over causation when there could just as well be a chain of causative factors?

    In other words, how is what Dr. Galanter says actually misleading? Does it matter whether the negative effects are due to direct action of the drug on the brain, if the outcome is the same?

    Monday, April 28, 2008 at 1:59 pm | Permalink
  4. Kara wrote:

    I think it does matter, because there are people who can smoke marijuana and won’t become depressed or lead unfulfilled lives. Your argument breaks down in the first step, smoking pot does not necessarily equate with not dealing with your issues.

    Why not state the correlation clearly and leave causation alone? Either way, drugs aren’t the problem, people being unhappy is. To paint drugs as the reason people are unhappy convolutes the issue of unhappiness and furthers people from really dealing with the source of their problems.

    In other words – I’m not binge-eating anymore. Am I any happier? No, you know and can see as well as I can that my emotional problems are still present. Can I pick out my emotional problems more easily – yes, but I still have to deal with them.

    Monday, April 28, 2008 at 2:36 pm | Permalink

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *
*
*